top of page


Dartmouth College v. Woodward (1819)
Background: In 1769, a royal charter was issued by King George III, establishing the private institution of Dartmouth College, subsequently creating a self-perpetuating twelve member board. In 1816, after a dispute between the board and the college's president, the New Hampshire legislature attempted to expand the board and modify Dartmouth College from a private institution to a state university. The old trustees of the board refused to recognize the changes made, and sued W
Aryanna Ault
Nov 92 min read


Griswold v. Connecticut (1965)
Background: November 1, 1961, the clinic, Planned Parenthood League of Connecticut opened in New Haven. It provided contraceptive devices along with counseling to married women. Staff examined patients, fitted diaphragms, and prescribed contraceptives. Among those working there were Estelle Griswold and Dr. C. Lee Buxton. Griswold was executive director of the Planned Parenthood League of Connecticut. Buxton was chair of obstetrics and gynecology at Yale School of Medicine. H
Aryanna Ault
Nov 13 min read


Terry v. Ohio (1968)
Background: In 1963, detective with the Cleveland Police Department, Martin McFadden watched John Terry and Richard Chilton repeatedly inspect a store. In a span of ten to twelve minutes he watched them alternate between peering inside, walking away, then returning, this occurred around six times. He suspected they were planning a robbery, and approached them, identifying himself. He asked what they were doing, and they mumbled an answer McFadden could not hear, so he conduct
Aryanna Ault
Oct 263 min read


Mapp v. Ohio (1961)
Background: The historical precedent behind this case originates from the American colonies, when British soldiers had the right to search homes of Americans whenever they desired. This therefore was addressed in the Bill of Rights under the Constitution's Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment prohibits the unwarranted search of a person or their property. On May 23, 1957 in Cleveland, Ohio, police officers, despite not having a warrant, entered and searched the home of Dol
Aryanna Ault
Oct 203 min read


Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)
Background: Prior to 2015, many states banned same-sex marriage or refused to recognize marriages between same-sex couples if performed in other states in which it was legal. Many same-sex couples argued that these restrictions violated the Fourteenth Amendment right to due process and equal protection under the law. July 19, 2013, James Obergefell sued the state of Ohio, after the state refused to recognize his marriage to his partner John Arthur, on Aurthur’s death certific
Aryanna Ault
Oct 113 min read


Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com (2019)
Background: The news organization, Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. which employs writers and produces online journalism, licenses articles to websites, however it retains the copyright to the articles. Instead of operating as a traditional consumer subscription site where individual people pay to read articles, Fourth Estate uses a business-to-business (B2B) syndication model. They license blocks of news articles to other websites, such as Wall-Street.com, allowing those s
Aryanna Ault
Oct 43 min read


Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife (1992)
Background: Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973 required U.S. federal agencies to consult with the Secretary of the Interior to ensure any actions they funded, authorized, or carried out did not jeopardize or harm endangered species or their habitats. Originally, a 1978 joint regulation applied this consultation requirement worldwide, including in foreign nations. In 1986, the Department of the Interior under the Reagan administration reinterpreted the rule
Aryanna Ault
Sep 283 min read


Massachusetts v. EPA (2007)
Background: October 20, 1999, Massachusetts and eleven other states petitioned the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), requesting EPA to regulate carbon dioxide emissions, along with other gasses contributing to global warming, particularly from new motor vehicles. The petitioning states relied on the Clean Air Act. The coalition of states included Massachusetts, California, Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and
Aryanna Ault
Sep 144 min read


McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
Background: In 1816, the United States Congress created the Second Bank of the United States. Later, in 1818, the state of Maryland passed a tax on all banks not chartered directly by the state. This was intended to specifically target the Baltimore branch of the Second Bank of the United States. This act would impose a $15,000 annual tax on any bank operating in the state not chartered by the state, or the mandatory issuing and use of bank notes of a specially stamped state
Aryanna Ault
Sep 63 min read


Bond v. United States
Background: Carol Anne Bond was married to Clifford Bond for 14 years. In 2006, her friend Myrlinda Haynes announced her pregnancy, of which Clifford Bond was the father. At this time, Carol Anne Bond worked for Rohm and Haas, a chemical manufacturer. Through her connections, Bond sought revenge on Haynes by purchasing highly toxic chemicals, which she applied to Haynes’ doorknobs, car handles, and mailbox. Between 2006 and 2007, Bond attempted to poison Haynes on at least 24
Aryanna Ault
Aug 303 min read


United States v. Wong Kim Ark
Background: Wong Kim Ark was born around 1873 in San Francisco, to Chinese immigrant parents, who ran a mercantile story in Chinatown. At the time of his birth, his parents were subjects to the Emperor of China, but had a permanent home and residence in the United States. Growing up, among rising anti-Chinese sentiments, Wong Kim Ark mostly worked as a cook at various restaurants in the area. Many Americans feared Chinese immigrants would increase job competition. It was ofte
Aryanna Ault
Aug 253 min read


Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard
Background: For decades prior to this case universities were allowed to consider race in admissions under certain circumstances. This meant they couldn’t simply give someone automatic admission due to race, but they could consider race as a holistic part of the admissions process. This framework was established by previous cases such as Grutter v. Bollinger. Harvard's admissions were considered to be a holistic process, considering activities such as extracurriculars, athleti
Aryanna Ault
Aug 113 min read


U.S. v. Lee (1882)
Background: In May 1861, during the American Civil War, the U.S. seized the Arlington Estate in Virginia, home of Confederate General Robert E. Lee’s family, due to property taxes which had not been paid in person. It was converted to be a refugee camp for runaway slaves, as well as a military cemetery, known today as the Arlington National Cemetery. Lee’s eldest son, George Washington Curtis Lee, argued the government's seizure was illegal as his mother had been prevented fr
Aryanna Ault
Aug 23 min read


De Lima v. Bidwell
Background: After the Spanish American War, Spain signed the Treaty of Paris, giving Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines to the United States. This therefore raised many constitutional questions, on how the United States would govern these newly acquired territories. Before the treaty, Puerto Rico was considered a foreign country under U.S. customs laws, so goods imported from the island were subject to tariffs. However, once Puerto Rico became U.S. territory, it was uncle
Aryanna Ault
Jul 263 min read


United States v. Lee (1982)
Background: Edwin Lee was a member of the Old Order Amish, and employed several other Amish workers on his farm and in his carpentry shop. The Amish believe in living separately from many aspects of modern society, and place strong emphasis on members of their Amish community caring for one another instead of relying on government support or welfare programs. Due to these religious beliefs, Lee objected to participating in the Social Security system. He specifically refused t
Aryanna Ault
Jul 193 min read


Nix v. Whiteside
Background: In 1977, Emmanuel Charles Whiteside was involved in a confrontation with a man named Calvin Love. What Whiteside claimed to be a drug related dispute escalated, and Whiteside stabbed Love to death. Whiteside was charged with second degree murder in Iowa. He claimed he acted out of self defense, as he believed Love was about to pull out a gun on him. Despite this, Whiteside admitted to his attorney that he had never actually seen a gun. Soon before taking the witne
Aryanna Ault
Jul 143 min read


Miranda v. Arizona
Background: Prior to the 1960’s police officers were not required to inform suspects of their constitutional rights before questioning them. Many confessed without knowing they had the right to remain silent, or have a lawyer present. The Fifth amendment of The U.S. Constitution protects against people being forced to testify against themselves. The Sixth amendment guarantees the right to legal counsel, or in other words, a lawyer. There was however, no consistent rule requir
Aryanna Ault
Jul 63 min read


Nix v. Hedden
Background: In the late 1800’s the United States imposed tariffs on imported vegetables at 10% ad valorem under the Tariff Act of 1883. Fruits were, however, exempt from this tariff. This was done to protect domestic truck drivers from foreign competition. At this time, John Nix & Co. was a business which imported produce. One of their imports was fresh tomatoes from the Caribbean. While entering the United States, the customs collector for the Port of New York, Edward L. Hed
Aryanna Ault
Jun 282 min read


State v. Leroy Reed
Background: Leroy Reed was a Milwaukee resident with a prior felony conviction. This was due to his assistance as the getaway driver in an armed robbery. He was released early from his sentence as it was determined that he did not realize he was a part of a crime. After he was released, Reed lived a quiet and law abiding life, acting as what many would call a model citizen. Leroy Reed possessed cognitive abilities significantly below average, and was noted to have a second gr
Aryanna Ault
Jun 223 min read


Dred Scott v. Sandford
Background: Prior to the American Civil War, states and territories in the United States were divided into two categories. Free states were states where slavery was prohibited, whereas slave states were states where slavery was legal. Born into slavery around 1799, Dred Scott was purchased in 1830 by Dr. John Emerson. Between 1833 and 1843, Emerson took Scott with him to various military posts, including Fort Armstrong in Illinois and Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory.
Aryanna Ault
Jun 153 min read
bottom of page