Dartmouth College v. Woodward (1819)

Background:
In 1769, a royal charter was issued by King George III, establishing the private institution of Dartmouth College, subsequently creating a self-perpetuating twelve member board. In 1816, after a dispute between the board and the college's president, the New Hampshire legislature attempted to expand the board and modify Dartmouth College from a private institution to a state university. The old trustees of the board refused to recognize the changes made, and sued William H. Woodward, the new treasurer the state had installed.
The Case:
The original board desired to recover the college’s seal, records, and property. The New Hampshire State Court rejected the trustees’ arguments, ruling in favor of Woodward. At the state appellate level, the New Hampshire Superior Court of Judicature upheld the state legislation after the trustees appealed the trial court’s decision. It was ruled that Dartmouth College was a public corporation, and therefore had the constitutional power to alter its charter and trustee structure. The original trustees, having lost in the state system, finally brought the case to the U.S. Supreme Court on a writ of error.
Debates From Each Side:
The plaintiffs, the college trustees claimed the 1769 royal charter is a binding contract that cannot be violated by the state under the U.S. Constitution. Article I, Section 10, under the Contract Clause, the U.S. Constitution prohibits states from passing laws that impair the obligation of contracts. It was proposed to be in the nature of the institution as a private entity funded by private donors, to allow their property to be entrusted under a specific board. It was maintained that the state altering the contract of the private institution would violate and strip property rights.
The State of New Hampshire, the defendants, contrastingly argued the college is a public corporation created for the good of the public, making it subject to state modification. Additionally, it was mentioned that the state succeeded the British Crown and inherited the right to alter civic, educational, and political relations. The argument was maintained that a public civil institution established to educate citizens belongs under the control of state elected officials.
Verdict:
The Supreme Court ruled in a 5-1 vote in favor of Dartmouth College. It was established that a corporate charter such as the one established by King George III was a private contract protected by the Constitution. The Contract Clause backed this ruling, making it so the legislature could not interfere with the board of the private corporation. Chief Justice John Marshall delivered the majority opinion, declaring the U.S. government cannot alter or impair the private contract established between parties.
Legacy:
Dartmouth College v. Woodward overall established the monumental legal precedent that corporate charters are protected under the U.S. Constitution's Contract Clause. By preventing the New Hampshire legislature from forcibly converting the private college into a public university, the Court greatly restricted the power of state governments to interfere with private contracts. This landmark supreme court ruling provided a secure legal foundation for the rise of the American free enterprise system by shielding business corporations from overcontrolling or unconstitutional state regulation. Ultimately, this decision fostered immense economic growth and investment in the United States by giving private enterprises the stability and confidence to expand without fear of political overreach, remaining extremely influential today.


Comments