Mapp v. Ohio (1961)

Background:
The historical precedent behind this case originates from the American colonies, when British soldiers had the right to search homes of Americans whenever they desired. This therefore was addressed in the Bill of Rights under the Constitution's Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment prohibits the unwarranted search of a person or their property.
On May 23, 1957 in Cleveland, Ohio, police officers, despite not having a warrant, entered and searched the home of Dollree Mapp, who was handcuffed by the officers. The Cleveland Police Officers entered under the belief that a suspect wanted in connection to a recent bombing, Virgil Ogletree, was hiding in Mapp’s home. They claimed to also be looking for a large amount of illegal gambling paraphernalia supposedly stored in the home. The search came up empty on both fronts, as officers found neither the suspect nor any gambling materials.
The Case:
In the search they did however find four books: Memoirs of a Hotel Man, Affairs of a Troubadour, London Stage Affairs, and Little Darlings. In addition they found obscene photographs and drawings, along with a gun, all of which were in the basement of the house. These items violated the Ohio law in which it was felony to knowingly be in possession of obscene items. Mapp was arrested and convicted for possession of these items, and sentenced to one to seven years in prison. Mapp claimed these items were not hers, insisting they must have belonged to a former boarder or renter who had left their belongings behind.
After her conviction in Fall 1957 in Ohio state Court, Mapp appealed to the Ohio District Court of Appeals, which upheld the lower court's decision. She believed it was a violation of her Fourth Amendment right to have evidence which was illegally seized without a warrant used against her in the court of law. Her conviction was subsequently maintained by the Ohio Supreme Court. Mapp then appealed to the Supreme Court.
Debates From Each Side:
Mapp, represented by Alexander L. Kearns and Bernard Berkman. Berkman was an attorney representing the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Ohio. The ACLU filed an influential amicus brief arguing that the Fourth Amendment's exclusionary rule should apply to state courts. The exclusionary rule is legal principle is a legal principle stating that evidence collected or analyzed in violation of the U.S. Constitution, primarily through unconstitutional searches and seizures, cannot be used in a court of law. This rule however, at the time only applied to federal courts. The petitioners argued that due to the evidence being illegally seized, Mapp could not be convicted of a crime, as it violated her Fourth Amendment right.
The State of Ohio, represented by Gertrude Bauer Mahon alongside John T. Corrigan, argued that the exclusionary rule did not apply in the state of Ohio as each state had the discretion to choose if it only was mandatory in federal courts. They relied on previous Supreme Court precedent such as Wolf v. Colorado, which held that while the Fourth Amendment applied to states through the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, the states were not required to use the federal exclusionary rule. Ohio maintained that individual states had the right to decide their own rules of evidence and could choose to admit illegally seized proof as long as the police did not use shocking or brutal physical force.
Verdict:
On June 19, 1961, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 6-3 vote that evidence obtained through a search and seizure that violates the Fourth Amendment is inadmissible in state criminal proceedings. The Court applied the exclusionary rule to state courts through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause, overturning the earlier precedent set in Wolf v. Colorado (1949). The U.S. Supreme Court reversed the Ohio court's decision, establishing that the constitutional protection against unreasonable searches and seizures requires excluding tainted evidence at all levels of government. Additionally, this was established as many believed if evidence could be used despite an illegal search and seizure, there was no motivation for police officers to get a warrant as there was no consequence.
Legacy:
This landmark Supreme Court decision established the exclusionary rule as precedent in state courts, protecting Fourth Amendment rights of defendants from illegal searches and seizures. This implied that warrantless searches were unconstitutional, and evidence could not be used in the court of law. This motivated police officers to get warrants, as previously it was possible to conduct an illegal search and seizure with no consequence as long as evidence was found to use in a conviction. This sparked greater transparency in police conduct, forcing greater accountability. Critics argue that this rule allows guilty individuals go free if technicalities and police conduct are not adhered to, some claiming this incentivizes police to stretch the truth or bypass rules through loopholes. Mapp v. Ohio continues to be debated today, especially as new technology becomes more prevalent in the lives of many.


It has to be almost unfathomable for people in this day and age to realize how oppressed women were. What brave souls to navigate this.