top of page

Terry v. Ohio (1968)

Writer: Aryanna Ault
Aryanna Ault
Oct 26
3 min read

Background:


In 1963, detective with the Cleveland Police Department, Martin McFadden watched John Terry and Richard Chilton repeatedly inspect a store. In a span of ten to twelve minutes he watched them alternate between peering inside, walking away, then returning, this occurred around six times. He suspected they were planning a robbery, and approached them, identifying himself. He asked what they were doing, and they mumbled an answer McFadden could not hear, so he conducted a pat-down. McFadden found a gun on both Terry and Chilton and arrested them. Terry was charged with carrying concealed weapons. 


The Case:


Terry moved to suppress the evidence, arguing it was the fruit of an unlawful search and seizure, violating his Fourth Amendment right. The trial court denied the motion, and Terry was convicted of the crime. Terry never contested that he was carrying a weapon, he argued whether the state had the right to find it in the way they did. Terry appealed the denial of suppression. Ohio’s intermediate appellate court affirmed the conviction. The Ohio Supreme Court affirmed the previous decision, that the conducted frisk did not violate constitutional rights.


Debates From Each Side:


Terry, represented by Louis Stokes, contended that The Fourth Amendment states probable cause is necessary and was not obtained to conduct the pat down. He maintained that from the moment the officer approached him the interaction was unconstitutional due to the lack of probable cause. Terry claimed this was an unlawful search and seizure, lacking the necessary warrant, eroding the standing of the Fourth Amendment. Terry relied on the exclusionary rule, which he claimed should be instituted given that the search was illegal, which would nullify the weapon as evidence in the trial. 

Ohio, represented by Reuben Payne, assistant prosecuting attorney for Cuyahoga County, argued that a police officer has an inherent right and duty to protect himself from potential harm when confronting suspects. Ohio maintained that a brief, limited pat-down of outer clothing for weapons is not a full search of technical arrest, excluding it from the strict requirements to conduct a search and seizure. The state asserted, an experienced officer, in this case of 40 years, must be allowed to use his trained judgement and observations to investigate suspicious behavior prior to a crime actually occurring.


Verdict:


The Supreme Court ruled in a 8-1 vote in favor of Ohio. Terry was convicted of the crime. Chief Justice Earl Warren wrote the majority opinion, holding that someone on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity and frisk them if they believe a person to be armed or dangerous. Justice William O. Douglas was the sole dissenter, arguing that allowing police to stop and frisk without a warrant or probable cause weakened the Fourth Amendment protections and risked giving officers powers not unlike those of a judge. The Court found that the officer in this particular case acted on more than a “hunch”, as the suspects presented a threat to officer McFadden’s safety as he was investigating the suspicious behavior.


Legacy:


This landmark Supreme Court case established when police may constitutionally stop and frisk a person they reasonably suspect is involved in a crime and may be armed. This became the foundation of modern street policing, leading to the subsequent cases of Adams v. Williams United States v. Sokolow, Where v. United States, and Minnesota v. Dickerson, extending the logic to “plain feel” contraband. This later made New York City’s stop-and-frisk program legally possible, before it was later ruled unconstitutional in Floyd v. City of New York for racially discriminatory application. The original assessment presents this doctrine on paper as narrow and defensible, allowing "reasonable suspicion” to be applied in real time by officers under pressure. Many contrastingly argue that courts largely have not adhered to the narrowness of the doctrine.This case remains precedent, however continues to be debated, maintaining incredible importance.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page