top of page

Griswold v. Connecticut (1965)

Writer: Aryanna Ault
Aryanna Ault
Nov 1
3 min read

Background:


November 1, 1961, the clinic, Planned Parenthood League of Connecticut opened in New Haven. It provided contraceptive devices along with counseling to married women. Staff examined patients, fitted diaphragms, and prescribed contraceptives. Among those working there were Estelle Griswold and Dr. C. Lee Buxton. Griswold was executive director of the Planned Parenthood League of Connecticut. Buxton was chair of obstetrics and gynecology at Yale School of Medicine. He was the medical director of the clinic.  Buxton and Griswold also gave medical advice to married couples about contraception, which triggered statute criminalizing anyone who advises the use of contraceptives. They operated for ten days, then, on November 10, 1961, police raided the clinic and arrested both Griswold and Buxton. 


The Case:


The clinic was a deliberate act of civil disobedience designed to produce a conviction that could be appealed to the Supreme Court. Connecticut had two statutes passed in 1879, one criminalizing the use of any drug or device to prevent conception, another making it a crime to advise anyone to use contraceptives.  Married couples couldn't legally get birth control. The law was almost never enforced against individuals; however it led to the arrest and blocked the operation of Planned Parenthood's New Haven clinic. Both Griswold and Buxton were convicted of violating these laws, and fined $100 in Connecticut’s trial court. The following state Appellate Division and Connecticut Supreme Court upheld the convictions. 


Debates From Each Side:


Griswold argued that the law invaded marital privacy. It was claimed the First, Third, Fourth, Fifth, and Ninth Amendments in the Bill of Rights cast penumbras or areas of privacy, protecting intimate relationships such as marriage. The Ninth Amendment specifically protects fundamental and unenumerated rights of the people that do not need to be listed word for word in the Constitution. There was a significant argument around the intrusion of police searching marital bedrooms for evidence of contraception use.

Connecticut contrastingly defended the already existing law. It was contended that the state elected lawmakers reflected the values of Connecticut citizens, and therefore had the authority to decide that artificial birth control was immoral and should be prohibited. The argument was made that the Constitution contains no general right to privacy, claiming the Court would be inventing constitutional law instead of simply reading and acting upon it. Similarly, it was contended that changing the law was the job of the state legislature not the courts.


Verdict:


In a 7-2 vote the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Griswold. It was established that the U.S. Constitution protects the fundamental right to marital privacy. This invalidated the preexisting Connecticut law which led to the original lawsuit. The majority opinion, written by Justice William O. Douglas declared: the state ban unconstitutionally intruded upon the right to privacy in a marital relationship, despite the Constitution not explicitly stating it. This was backed by the implied rights created by the penumbras in the Bill of Rights. The Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause was also heavily relied upon, framing the right of ordered liberty. Dissenting opinions claimed the judiciary should not invent a constitutional right to privacy where the text does not explicitly provide one. 


Legacy:


This landmark Supreme Court case  not only established the protection of marital relations from state intrusion, but also expanded logic and paved the way for later rulings. This case was extremely influential in Eisenstadt v. Baird (1972) which similarly created protection to unmarried individuals regarding the use of and access to contraception. It also became a vital cornerstone to the later rulings of Roe v. Wade (1973), Lawrence v. Texas (2003), and Obergefell v. Hodges (2015). This case remains extremely influential even now, continuing to shape laws and rulings, broadening the scope of privacy protection.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page