Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. v. Wall-Street.com (2019)

Background:
The news organization, Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corp. which employs writers and produces online journalism, licenses articles to websites, however it retains the copyright to the articles. Instead of operating as a traditional consumer subscription site where individual people pay to read articles, Fourth Estate uses a business-to-business (B2B) syndication model. They license blocks of news articles to other websites, such as Wall-Street.com, allowing those sites to feature high-quality news on their own platforms. Wall-Street.com is a digital news, financial commentary, and online media website operated at the time of the case by Jerrold Burden.
The Case:
Wall-Street.com obtained licenses to several articles produced by Fourth Estate, which they published to readers. Under the license agreement, if Wall-Street.com were to cancel its account, it was required to completely remove all of the content produced by Fourth Estate from its website prior to taking that action. Despite this, when Wall-Street cancelled its account, it continued to display the articles produced by Fourth Estate. Fourth Estate had submitted applications to register the articles with the Copyright Office, but the Copyright Office had not yet actually processed or acted on those applications by the time of the case. In response to the actions of Wall-Steet.com, Fourth Estate filed a copyright infringement lawsuit. The district court dismissed the lawsuit, finding that registration under Section 411 of the Copyright Act required the register of copyrights to have registered a claim, which did not occur. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed this decision.
Debates From Each Side:
Fourth Estate argued copyright registration is complete when the owner submits the correct application, fee, and deposit. They maintained that enforcement of private property rights should not depend on administrative backlogs at the Copyright Office. It was claimed, the phrase "registration has been made" in Section 411(a) cross-references a copyright owner’s compliance under Section 408(a) rather than an affirmative act by the government. Fourth Estate raised the issue that waiting months or years for the Copyright Office to process an application leaves creators vulnerable to ongoing infringement, which becomes unpreventable during the delay window.
Wall-Street stated the argument that registration occurs strictly when the Copyright Office reviews and approves the registration. On this point, it would diminish statutory harmony, to interpret applications alone as registration, as it would make subsequent statutory sentences such as Copyright Office refusals and registry certificates superfluous. They subsequently argued that administrative delay forces copyright holders to apply promptly before infringement occurs rather than rushing applications post-infringement. It was also brought up that statutory text explicitly distinguishes between the applicant's submission and the official act of registration by the Register.
Verdict:
The United States Supreme Court ruled in a unanimous vote in favor of Wall-Street.com. On March 14, 2019, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote the majority opinion, stating a copyright owner cannot file an infringement lawsuit merely by submitting an application; they must wait until the U.S. Copyright Office officially registers or refuses the copyright claim. This was backed under title 17 of the United States Code, in the Copyright Act (17 U.S.C. § 411(a)) which clearly states, copyright registration occurs when the U.S. Copyright Office processes and registers a copyright, not when a party simply submits an application. This case instituted the official interpretation and final ruling defining what “registration has been made" means under this statute.
Legacy:
This landmark Supreme Court Case in U.S. copyright law defined registration for copyrights, and implemented new precedent to resolve prior infringement. The Court resolved a circuit split by adopting the "registration approach", while allowing owners to sue for past infringements once registration is finalized. This maintained the statutory harmony, allowing copyrights to only be administered once approved by the U.S. Copyright Office. Due to the verdict of this influential case, The Register of Copyrights subsequently refused registration for the specific articles debated upon. Without a valid registration, Fourth Estate could not legally refile or pursue the infringement action. This case not only is significant due to the impact it had on these two organizations and the debate between the published articles, it remains relevant today, as precedent for registration of copyrights, impacting many cases to follow.


Comments