Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)

Background:
Prior to 2015, many states banned same-sex marriage or refused to recognize marriages between same-sex couples if performed in other states in which it was legal. Many same-sex couples argued that these restrictions violated the Fourteenth Amendment right to due process and equal protection under the law. July 19, 2013, James Obergefell sued the state of Ohio, after the state refused to recognize his marriage to his partner John Arthur, on Aurthur’s death certificate, after he had passed away from ALS. This lawsuit was later combined with similar cases in Michigan, Kentucky, and Tennessee.
The Case:
The cases in which Obergefell v. Hodges was combined with included DeBoer v. Snyder, Bourke v. Beshear, and Tanco v. Haslam. In DeBoer v. Snyder, April DeBoer and Jayne Rowse challenged Michigan’s restrictions on same-sex couples adopting children jointly. In Bouruke v. Beshear, four same sex couples, all married in other jurisdictions, being Canada, Iowa, California, and Connecticut, challenged Kentucky's refusal to recognize their marriages. Tanco v. Haslam, in Tennessee, was filed by the National Center for Lesbian Rights regarding three same-sex couples who had been married out of state, yet were not recognized in marriage by the state of Tennessee. When brought to the Federal District Courts, all four rulings favored the couples, however in November 2014, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the lower courts. In April 28, 2015, oral arguments were presented to the United States Supreme Court.
Debates From Each Side:
The petitioners argued, the Fourteenth Amendment protects fundamental liberties, which includes the right to marry. Under the same logic, it was presented that denying same-sex couples the right to marry is unequal treatment under the law. It was contended that marriage provides legal protections, security, and recognition for couples and their families. They advocated that couples should not lose the legal recognition of their marriages simply by crossing state borders.
The respondents, including various state and health officials, defending state marriage laws, debated that states and their voters should dictate and decide how marriage is defined rather than having the Supreme Court impose a nationwide law. It was similarly argued that marriage had traditionally been defined in law as a union between a man and a woman. The states contested that the Constitution does not explicitly mention same-sex marriage, and believed the Court should not interpret the Fourteenth Amendment as creating that right. Some opponents adduced that recognizing same-sex marriage could create conflicts with some religious beliefs or practices.
Verdict:
On June 26, 2015, the Supreme Court ruled in a 5-4 vote in favor of the petitioners. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote the majority opinion, joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan. It was held that the Fourteenth Amendment requires every state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples on the same terms as opposite-sex couples, as well as recognize same-sex marriages legally performed in other states. This argument relied on the Due Process Clause and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
Legacy:
This landmark Supreme Court Case allowed for the legal marriage of same-sex couples regardless of state, therefore permitting equal legal protections granted to opposite-sex marriages. This included access to inheritance rights, spousal benefits, and medical decision-making protections. This ruling became an important example of how constitutional protections of liberty and equality can be applied to previously excluded groups from those legal rights. Obergefell v. Hodges remains important precedent in constitutional law, and extends beyond marriage equality, relevant in broader debates regarding the role of the Supreme Court, judicial power, and constitutional interpretations.



Comments